film no. 1
- Hal Roach's Rascals in Our Gang
(VHS/DVD) from C. W. Films
- This is a hybrid version deriving from various home movie sources. The VHS was available briefly on eBay
in the spring of 2003, and the DVD was first offered on eBay in October 2004. The opening and closing titles are new. The
inter-titles are sometimes original, but sometimes derive from 9.5mm sources from the UK. The picture quality is
generally good. The print totals 12:45, with 11:05 of original footage. Roughly half of the original film is
included. This version has appeared on at least one bootleg, but it should be advised that an improved C. W. version is
scheduled to appear on the upcoming Laughsmith set.
- Rascals Silents Vol. 4 (VHS/DVD) from
- This is a copy of the C. W. Films release.
- Kid Gangs And Juvenile Stars (DVD) from
Looser Than Loose Publishing
- Released 2007. This is a home movie fragment from Exclusive Movie Studios, Inc., entitled "Donkey
Delivery Company," and contains 2:42 of original footage.
- other releases
- A homemade VHS appeared on eBay in Sep. 2004 containing "Donkey Delivery Company." The picture
quality on the VHS was fair, suffering mainly from the left side of the screen being slightly out of focus. The original
footage totaled 2:42. At the beginning of June 2005, a DVD appeared on eBay containing the same home movie. Both of
these releases disappeared after a small handful of copies were sold.
- special note
- When Maltin & Bann wrote the first edition of their book in 1977, they considered this to be a lost
film. And this is at least partially true, since to this day, no complete copy is known to exist. However, in the second
edition (from 1992), they had been able to view a fragment, and had also learned that two versions of the film had
been made. I suspect they may have been viewing the home movie entitled "Who's A Sissy," since they added
Mickey Daniels to their cast listing at that point. It's almost certain that whatever footage they viewed is contained
within the C. W. Films version.
- So far, I haven't seen any good evidence of the original pilot version of the film surviving, but the
A-Haunting We Will Go tent of the Sons of the Desert screened a digest version that they thought might have derived
from that first version.
- The American Film Institute restored a 9.5mm reel from Australia deriving from this film and exhibited it in January
Conceived probably in late 1921, not in mid-winter 1922, as Maltin & Bann state.
Filmed January 3 to 19, and February 2 to 17, 1922. See the 'miscellaneous' section below for more details.
The 1977 version of the book also states that the film was announced to the trade press in August, but then, during the
section on "One Terrible Day" (no. 4), extends this to an announcement referring to the entire series.
This would have still been prior to the first general release of the series.
Copyrighted October 11, 1922, by Pathé Exchange, Inc. Registration no. LU18302. Since the copyright was not
renewed, this film is now in the public domain.
Released November 5, 1922. It was the 3rd film in the series to be released.
Probable opening title: 'Hal Roach presents His Rascals in "Our Gang".' The '"Our
Gang" Comedies' heading would not have been used for the first version of the film, since the film title is what
lead to the series name. However, the remake probably carried it, especially since the lobby poster does. Also used
variously during the first year were '"Our Gang" Comedy' and '"Our Gang" Series.'
- Produced by Hal Roach
- Probably credited in the film as a presenter.
- Supervised by Charles Parrott
- Better known as Charley Chase; the film probably includes this credit. Parrott was
director-general of all of the studio's output during this period.
- Directed by Fred Newmeyer and
Robert F. McGowan
- Maltin & Bann reveal Newmeyer as the original director in the text section, but don't include his
name in the credits. Presumably, he received on-screen credit in the original but not in the remake. McGowan directed
the remake, and was probably credited (but without the middle initial).
- Titles by H. M. Walker
- This credit probably appears in the film.
- Story by Hal E. Roach
- This credit probably doesn't appear in the film.
- Released by Pathé Exchange, Inc.
- Passed by the National Board of Review
- Probably indicated in the film.
- studio personnel
- possible uncredited involvement
- Ernie "Sunshine Sammy" Morrison
- Featured role. He definitely appears in the remake, and almost certainly in the original version.
He's essentially the leader of the gang in this film, having most of the ideas, and is featured strongly throughout
the surviving footage. Maltin & Bann indicate that the "Sunshine Sammy" moniker was used, but this isn't
the case in the existing footage. In the fragment screened by the Sons of the Desert, his name is given as "Sunny
Jim," but even this may not be from an original inter-title. This is the same name used in one of the UK 9.5mm
extracts. At one point in the original titles, the boys called him "Snowy," but this appears to be a bit of
- John Hatton
- Featured role. He's the boy in the Little Lord Fauntleroy outfit who switches clothes with Ernie and
becomes one of the gang. He's strongly featured throughout the surviving footage, and also has a lot of the ideas
behind sabotaging the rival merchant's store. The non-original inter-titles refer to him as "Patrick
Melrose," with the nickname "Pat."
- Anna Mae Bilson as "Mary Jane"
- Featured role. She's featured strongly throughout the surviving footage, and is pivotal to the plot,
since she's part of the romantic triangle, and also is in danger of being put out on the street with her mother if
they don't come up with the rent. Some of the UK footage changes her character name to "Flora," while in
other parts it's "Mary." The name "Mary Jane" is from the original titles.
- Mickey Daniels
- Small part. He's the only member of the 'gang' besides Ernie that is given anything specific
to do, since he fetches a doll from a nearby girl to coax Pat behind a fence so that the gang can steal his clothes for
Ernie. In the surviving footage, his is little more than a bit part.
- Jackie Condon
- Small part. He appears as (presumably) Jimmy's little brother, who advises him to refine
himself if he wants to compete with Pat. This is a fairly small part for Jackie, at least in the surviving footage. It
isn't absolutely clear whether or not he appeared in the pilot version of the film.
- other kids
- Supporting role and bit parts.
(1.) The tall boy that appears in the first part of the surviving footage, trying to start a romantic relationship
with Mary Jane, but she falls for the more refined Pat. The non-original text-titles refer to him as
(2.) The girl who hands her doll to Mickey. This may be the girl that Maltin & Bann listed as Mary Kornman in
the second edition of their book, but I don't think it's her, even if she's wearing a brunette wig.
(3.) Five more boys in the gang.
- questionable listings
- Peggy Cartwright is listed by Maltin & Bann, but I've yet to see any evidence of her inclusion in
this film. They also state that 'perhaps' Monty O'Grady and Winston and Weston Doty appear, but there are no
identical twins in the surviving footage, and their identification of O'Grady in other films has turned out to be
George "Freckles" Warde.
- Dinah the Mule
- Supporting role. Dinah gets a fair amount of screentime in the surviving footage, kicking various objects
(including people) towards various destinations for speedy delivery. In this film, she belongs to
- pony 001
- Supporting role. The pony is owned in this film by Pat, and assists the boys in their act of sabotage.
The UK footage uses the name "Dobbin" for the pony, but the titles aren't original.
- dog 001
- Supporting role. This dog appears more often than any other during the first couple of years of the
series. In this film, the kids make him look like a mad dog to scare customers away from the rival merchant. The
non-original text-titles refer to him as "Bonzo."
- other animals
- Bit parts.
(1.) Mary Jane's dog, who drops her doll into the creek so Jimmy can rescue it.
(2.) A puppy that sucks on the fingers of a rubber glove, thinking it's a cow's udder.
(3.) A cat sitting in a box at the beginning of the film, with perhaps other cats sleeping in the box, but I'm
not quite sure.
(4.) Five dogs chasing after the bad guy at the end of the film, one of which should be dog 001, and one of which
may be dog 007.
- Wallace Howe as the rival merchant
- Supporting role. He's the skinflint who uses dishonest methods to drive the widow out of business.
Conveniently, he's also her landlord, and is ready to throw her out on the street if she can't come up with the
rent. When the gang gets involved, he eventually leaves town. He has a fairly substantial part in this film, but only
appears in the latter half of the surviving footage. The non-original text-titles refer to him as "Mr.
Jacobson." Maltin & Bann list John Hatton in this role, but it turns out that he's one of the
- Fanny Kelly as the rich boy's mother
- Small part. She appears briefly and faints at the sight of her transformed son.
- Mark Jones as "Emil"
- Small part. This is the drunk who gets delivered to his home via mule-kick. The original
text-titles reveal his character name.
- Charley Young as one of the customers
- Small part. This is pretty much a guess, since it's hard to tell, but he's the man being waited
on by Pat. His purchase is the first to be delivered by mule power.
- Helen Gilmore as Emil's wife
- Bit part. She requests assistance with her drunken husband.
- other adults
- Supporting roles, small parts, bit parts and extras.
(1.) Mary Jane's widowed mother who runs the village store. She's given a fair amount of screen time in
the latter half of the surviving footage. The non-original text-titles refer to her as "Mrs. Nickol."
Maltin & Bann list Anna Mae Bilson in this role, but this is clearly an error.
(2.) The woman who needs a hat, so the pony steals one for her from the rival merchant.
(3.) The woman who plays Ernie's mom early in the film. Could possibly be a white man in blackface.
(4.) The woman accompanying Kelly.
(5.) The man who comes to assist Kelly when she faints. We don't get a chance to see his face.
(6.) There are several other adults serving as customers for both the widow and the rival merchant. Two women
faint at the sight of the 'mad dog,' one of whom might be Patsy O'Byrne, who Richard Bann has added to
his cast listing. Another woman is seen as Charley Young's wife as he walks up to his door. In total, there are
perhaps fifteen adults in the surviving footage.
- Motor Avenue and Woodbine Street, Palms district, Los Angeles
- After Jimmy gets himself guzzied up, he appears at the northeast corner of this intersection, and Mary
Jane walks away with him. The brick building is the People's Water Company, located at 3392 Motor Avenue. In
the distance, we see the northwest corner, which doesn't yet have the familiar Palms Chamber of Commerce park bench
(as seen in no. 37, "The Love Bug").
- the street names on the sidewalk
- Ernie writes the following street names on the sidewalk: Central Ave., Elm St., Main St., and Broad
St. It's pretty clear that none of these streets have any relation to the actual locations used in the film. Even in
the scene with the street names, it appears that the Roach studio provided the setting.
A total of 29 shooting dates went into the making of this film. According to the studio datebook for 1922, filming
began Jan. 3rd, and was 'finished' on the 5th, suggesting that things weren't going well. Filming resumed the
next day and continued until Jan. 17th. No shooting took place on the 8th or the 15th, which were Sundays. Retakes were
shot on the 18th and 19th.
After one or more initial previews, retakes resumed on Feb. 2nd and continued until Feb. 17th. No filming took place on
the 5th or on the 12th, which were Sundays.
The Progressive Silent Film List website run by Carl Bennett states that the film was completely reshot on the February
dates. This is also what Maltin & Bann say, except that they state that it was initially filmed in the late spring,
and after having been previewed during the summer, was remade during the time the second and third films in the series
were released (in October and late November). But they contradict themselves by mentioning an early April preview
(which was reviewed in the April 8th Moving Picture World). It appears that this preview must have been for
There were 40 copies of this film printed for its initial release.
©Jan. 3, 2005, by Robert Demoss.
2005 updates: 1/7, 1/8, 2/27, 3/8, 3/17, 3/24, 4/25, 7/9, 8/7.
2006 updates: 1/9, 493, 6/12, 7/8, 10/25.
2007 updates: 4/1, 10/20, 10/22, 11/16.
2008 updates: 2/3, 3/18, 3/31, 4/25. 4/26, 7/6.
2009 updates: 1/18; 5/17, 5/18, 5/22, 6/17, 7/23.
Thanks to Robin Cook, Greg Lawrence, Rob Stone and Joe Moore for assistance on this page.